High country residents find partial solutions to health care costs
April 7, 2017
Editor’s note: This is the last story in a six-part series about health care costs in the Colorado mountains.
The arid garden of affordable health care has sprouted some promising blooms in Colorado's mountain valleys, thanks to innovation, generosity and cooperation.
In Pitkin County, a five-way partnership covering 21 percent of the people in the county, and emphasizing nutrition, weight loss and everyday health, has helped stem annual price bumps and even prompted a decline in premium costs for county employees.
It's called the Valley Health Alliance, comprising employees and their families of Aspen Skiing Company, Aspen Valley Hospital, Aspen School District, the City of Aspen and Pitkin County. It is one of the many Accountable Care Organizations that have sprung up since the advent of the Affordable Care Act.
The two variables of health care are cost and usage, Pitkin County Manager Jon Peacock said. Keep the employees healthier, and total costs go down, even if the per-visit costs do not.
The emphasis on primary-care relationships, in which ailments and chronic conditions are spotted and treated early and efficiently, is beginning to pay dividends. By focusing on nutrition, weight loss, high blood pressure and stress, primary care doctors can stay ahead of problems that can cost thousands of dollars later.
It has saved so much money that the people who work for the county haven't had a premium bump in three years, and last year, there was a 15 percent decrease in what the insurance company charged the employer, Peacock said.
The alliance wouldn't have worked without buy-in from the hospital and other health providers in the county, Peacock said. "We created a partnership between payers and providers."
Recently, the alliance offered $200 to any member who showed up at a health fair and then brought the results of the blood tests to his or her primary care doctor for analysis and conversation.
With the county paying about $10,600 a year for health premiums per worker — and at least double that for a family of four — the $200 sop was money well spent, Peacock said.
Large employers in Pitkin County had been getting killed by the annual spikes in premium costs, which were typically double the inflation rate, Peacock said. "We wanted to preserve the vitality of our local provider community, but we needed them to realize we can't continue to foot these bills."
Now it looks like it is paying off.
"We put a lot of energy into it," Peacock said. "I wish we had a silver bullet, but frankly, I don't think there is one. I do know that organization needs to happen at a local level just as much as on a national level. If you want to decrease costs, you have to have a five- to 10-year vision of success."
It's about building strategic relationships," said Kathleen Killion, VHA's executive director, who hopes the VHA model can spread to communities throughout Colorado. She said such alliances "can position Colorado as having its act together relative to transformational health care services."
Health savings accounts
Aspen Skiing Company gives its employees with families a $2,500 Health Savings Account each year, said spokesman Jeff Hanle. It inspires them to shop around for the biggest discounts they can find.
When the employee or a family member finds a good deal, it saves money because there is still money left in the HSA for the next medical need. And that saves money for Aspen Skiing Company, which, like many larger companies, self-insures.
"It's been an important benefit, I can tell you that from personal experience," Hanle said.
Aspen Skiing Co. also offers many counseling and exercise classes for employees. "Stretching, yoga, diet, education classes," Hanle said. "We do everything we can to keep them healthy," with the idea that healthy people are going to use medical services less.
Elsewhere, employers out of necessity are finding ways to save money for themselves and their employees. Colorado PERA, the pension system for teachers and state employees, carved out a special contract with one health system to try to save money on knee and hip replacements. PERA negotiated a steep discount, with the provider in return for assuring that provider that a lot of business would surely come its way. Why? Because PERA also told its members that if they went through that provider, PERA would waive all the deductibles and co-pays, saving the individual retiree a lot of money.
Employers can be creative in other ways, too, including not treating all their employees the same. Lindsay noted his former employer, Lockton, puts money into a Health Savings Account for all its employees — but puts in more for those earning less than $50,000 than for those earning more.
"It's just in recognition that those earning less needed more help."
Help for low-income residents
Instead of complaining about the extra costs that the Medicaid population brings to health care, clinics and hospitals here are showing that the system can work.
The Colorado Mountain Family Health Clinics have sites in Glenwood Springs, Rifle, Basalt, Edwards, Avon and El Jebel, serving people who are at the federal poverty level or just slightly above.
Aspen Valley Hospital contributed space and equipment and other providers have contributed time and equipment.
The key to its success, says CEO Ross Brooks, is that it:
• Emphasizes preventive care
• Tries to connect each customer to a primary care physician
• Combines medical, dental and mental health care under one roof, and trains personnel to be on the lookout for those needs whenever they see patients.
• Saves money by reducing unnecessary trips to the emergency room, thus tamping down the rise in insurance premiums.
The best part is that the clients "are living healthier lives," Brooks said.
In all, Mountain Family serves 17,000 people. About half are on Medicaid, most of the rest are uninsured because of their immigrant status. Just a handful are young, healthy people who chose to pay the tax penalty rather than pay for insurance, Brooks said.
Brooks said health care costs are rising much faster in the commercial insurance market than in the Medicaid population. "Why does our population cost half as much? I don't believe the lives of the poor are worth half as much."
Rather than scapegoating Medicaid or gutting it, lawmakers should take note that "investment in upfront primary care for the poor has saved the system billions of dollars," Brooks said.
"We're proud to be their partner," Peacock said, speaking for the county. "We want folks to have primary care physicians. We don't want to treat them in the emergency rooms — the least effective way."
Brooks wants to see more transparency in costs, so consumers and employers, not just health professionals, can see that while one hospital or out-patient clinic might charge $5,000 for a procedure, another will charge just $2,500. Software tools such as Health Advocate would be a boon to employers who self-insure, he said.
Still, Brooks laments that Mountain Family Clinics are reaching only about half of the low-income people in its areas. "There are more than 35,000 people here living on $24,000 a year or less," he said. "Our goal is to reach 75 percent — and when we reach that, we'll reset the goal for 90 percent."
Measuring quality by value
There are two ways to lower prices. One is the blunt instrument of demanding that providers accept a substantial discount from the insurer.
The other is more subtle and is called payment reform: pay doctors and other providers based on the quality of service they provide and the value their services contribute to the health of the individual and the community.
"We have to incentivize the physician, give him or her the latitude to experiment on ways to improve the value and reduce the cost," said Bill Lindsay, chairman of the Colorado Commission on Affordable Health Care.
For years, hospital quality was defined by such things as infection rates, how quickly patients were discharged, and the rate of positive incomes, Aspen Valley CEO Dave Ressler said. The new paradigm pushed by The Affordable Care Act — value — is more focused on cradle-to-grave health, healthy lifestyles and efficient care. "How the whole system keeps them healthy, reducing overall resource costs. We are happy to be part of that."
After Children's Hospital of Denver started looking at value, it made a significant switch in how it treated children who came to the ER with symptoms of appendicitis. Historically, 90 percent of the kids would be given an MRI, which not only is very expensive, but exposes the child to radiation.
Children's suggested to its doctors to only give MRIs when the appendicitis symptoms seem to indicate a complicated case. That brought the MRI rate down from 90 percent to 15 percent. "That is a significant savings and, I would argue, better medicine," Lindsay said.
But isn't that letting the bean counters dictate health decisions? many would ask. Well, yes, but you can't let health care swallow up the entire economy in the name of offering every incrementally better test for everyone, say the people who advocate for affordable coverage for all.
When it is your wife or child who has lower back pain, it makes perfect sense that she get the best possible imaging test to ensure that the best possible course of treatment is followed. But when it is 1,000 MRIs performed on 1,000 strangers, well, maybe some of those imaging tests probably weren't necessary at all.
It's called cognitive dissonance, the ability to hold contradictory views on a single subject. And while it's been absolutely crucial to the survival and prosperity of the human species, it makes the goal of affordable health care for all much more complex.
Championing affordable care that features the relationship between the primary care physician and the patient could have a downward effect on hospital revenues. Peacock applauds local hospitals for realizing that and saying, "even so, it's the right way to deliver health care in a community."
It's as much a mandate as it is altruistic, says Aspen Valley CFO Terry Collins. If America can't find a way to rein in health care costs, the whole system is in danger of collapse, he said.
More primary care docs
One proven way to lower health costs is to have a greater ratio of primary care physicians — family doctors, internists and pediatricians. But the trend is going in the wrong direction, nationally, in Colorado, and in the mountain valleys of the state, says Kim Marvel, executive director of the Colorado Association of Family Medicine.
Studies have shown that regions that have more than their share of primary care physicians per capita have lower overall health care costs, Marvel said. He cited a study that found that when there are only two family or internal medicine physicians per 10,000 people, the average health care costs are 33 percent higher than when there are five PCPs per 10,000 people.
The region needs another 22 primary care physicians to meet the goal of one PCP for every 1,900, according to CHI's Colorado's Primary Care Workforce: A Study of Regional Disparities. That would be an increase of 30 percent. But in Colorado, family doctors are retiring faster than they're being replaced, Marvel said.
Ironically, Obamacare exacerbated the shortage of family doctors, because with 20 million extra people gaining insurance, the PCPs are stretched even thinner, Marvel said.
The research demonstrates that when most of the population has access to primary care, treatment is more likely to occur before severe problems develop, and there are fewer unnecessary trips to the hospital and ER, Marvel said. Also, primary-care doctors tend to use fewer tests and are better at protecting people from over-treatment. Especially for the poor, access to a family doctor correlates with better blood pressure, more vaccines and reduced mortality.
Countries with the best health outcomes have a physician mix that includes 40 percent to 50 percent primary care physicians — family doctors, internists and pedicatricians, Marvel said. In the United States, only a third of doctors are PCPs, and currently only a fifth of medical school students are on the PCP track.
Medical school is expensive and most graduate with huge loans to repay, so the incentive is there to go into a high-priced specialty. Specialists typically earn double to four times the annual income of PCPs.
If medical students do their residencies in rural areas, they are much more likely to establish practices there, Marvel said. But of the 13 residencies that require at least some time spent in rural Colorado, the only one in the mountain resort region is in Basalt and requires just one month there out of a three-year residency.
A break for locals
The mountain communities have one eye on the long-term solutions but the other eye on the short-term solutions needed to stop the bleeding.
State Rep. Diane Mitsch Bush introduced a bill to give financial help to that next tier of households — those that earn between 400 percent and 500 percent of the federal poverty level, considered well-off in some corners of the state, but just barely getting by in resort towns with high costs for everything from housing to child care
• The Pitkin, Summit, Garfield, Eagle and Routt region is the most expensive area of the state to buy health insurance
• It has a higher percentage of people buying insurance on the individual market — 20 percent vs. 8 percent statewide
• And it has a higher rate of uninsured — about 11 percent vs. 6.7 percent statewide.
Residents who are aware of those stats readily see the connection between the first two numbers and the third.
That's why they continue to push for cooperation from the rest of the state. If you want our water, want to ski on our slopes, swim in our hot springs, hike our trails, how about sharing the cost of health care?
In the meantime, there are no laws against hospitals and doctors in the mountain regions offering two-tiered pricing — a lower rate for locals, a higher rate for outsiders, say, people from Texas or California who spend a day, a week, or a season in the high country, Lindsay said.
It can get tricky — does a local utility bill prove you are a local resident? — but it is worth doing, and a way to lower premiums for the majority of full-time residents of Garfield, Eagle, Pitkin, Routt and Summit counties, he said.