Angel Castro’s son, Aaron, 3, watches a movie after his evening bath while Castro feeds dinner to his sister, Alexis, 17 months, at their Englewood apartment. Castro, 28, a single mother relying heavily on public assistance, quit her part-time job after losing child care for the two children. Single parenthood is a bigger indicator of poverty than race, according to six decades of U.S. census data analyzed by I-News Network. Combined as it often is with curtailed educational and employment opportunities, the rise of the single-parent family is a major factor in the widening disparities between blacks, Latinos and white state residents since the decades surrounding the civil rights movement.

Joe Mahoney/I-News Network

Angel Castro’s son, Aaron, 3, watches a movie after his evening bath while Castro feeds dinner to his sister, Alexis, 17 months, at their Englewood apartment. Castro, 28, a single mother relying heavily on public assistance, quit her part-time job after losing child care for the two children. Single parenthood is a bigger indicator of poverty than race, according to six decades of U.S. census data analyzed by I-News Network. Combined as it often is with curtailed educational and employment opportunities, the rise of the single-parent family is a major factor in the widening disparities between blacks, Latinos and white state residents since the decades surrounding the civil rights movement.

Losing Ground: Family disintegration weighs on state of Colorado

Advertisement

Losing Ground

When it comes to statistical measurements of household income, education and health care, gaps between whites and minorities have widened significantly in the past 40 years. The I-News Network's “Losing Ground” series explores the complex reasons why.

Affordable child care, housing major hurdles for single parents

Raising a family as a single parent in resort communities like Steamboat Springs can be especially challenging.

LIFT-UP of Routt County Executive Director David Freseman said there are two major challenges that single parents face. The first is housing.

“They’re trying to subside in a costly place to live on one income,” Freseman said.

Finding affordable child care is the other big challenge. Oftentimes, single parents will rely on family to help care for the kids while the parent is working.

According to Routt County Department of Human Services Director Vickie Clark, families with only one parent contribute highly to the poverty rate nationally. That likely also is the case here in Routt County, where a parent with a preschool-age child needs to make $60,620 in order to pay expenses, according to the 2011 Self Sufficiency Standard for Colorado. Housing accounts for $12,732 in expenses, and child care costs are a whopping $19,056 annually.

At LIFT-UP, Freseman said the organization’s statistics show that 61 single-parent households were served in 2012. He thinks the true number likely is higher given that LIFT-UP served 1,386 total households in 2012.

“We serve a lot of single parents,” Freseman said.

— Matt Stensland, Steamboat Pilot & Today

Editor’s note: “Losing Ground” is the culmination of 18 months of investigative reporting done by a veteran team of award-winning journalists at the I-News Network, the public service journalism arm of Rocky Mountain PBS. This is the second in the four-part series that will appear on consecutive Sundays in the Steamboat Pilot & Today through Feb. 10, 2013.

Angel Castro’s days teeter between determination and desperation. She is 28, impoverished, scarred from a chaotic childhood and adolescence, raising two young children alone.

She lives in a subsidized apartment in Englewood, scrambles to arrange child care that she can afford and races to catch the bus to a part-time job that paid her $452 for one recent month.

To know the circumstances of Castro’s life is to understand something about the odds against her. Still, as she attends to her dark-haired, bright-eyed Aaron, 3, and Alexis, 17 months, she speaks with a voice that musters hope.

“I try to be the best mom I can,” she said. “I want to give my kids a chance at a healthy lifestyle. I want them to go to school, get good grades, be able to go to college and have a good future.”

Single parents and poverty

In analyzing the widening gaps between minority groups and whites in Colorado on key measures of social progress, there are harsh realities behind the numbers. One is that among homes with children living in poverty, 68 percent are headed by just one parent, typically the mother.

Single parenthood is a bigger indicator of poverty than race, according to six decades of U.S. Census Bureau data analyzed by I-News Network. Combined as it often is with curtailed educational and employment opportunities, the rise of the single-parent family is a major factor in the widening disparities between blacks, Latinos and white state residents since the decades surrounding the civil rights movement.

The I-News analysis covered family income, poverty rates, high school and college graduation, and home ownership as reported by the Census Bureau from 1960 to 2010. Health data and justice reports also were examined.

While the rate of single parenthood has increased among all races, its surge has been particularly dramatic among blacks. In Colorado, more than 50 percent of black households with young children are headed by a single parent compared to 25 percent of white households. Among Latino households in the state with young children, 35 percent are headed by a single parent, according to the I-News analysis.

Those figures dovetail with the growing trend of births to single women. Nationally, 29 percent of white babies are born to unwed mothers, according to the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, while 53 percent of Hispanic babies and 73 percent of black babies are born to single mothers.

“When you talk with some of the older experienced folks of the civil rights movement, the one thing that we continue to come back to is the challenged family structure — African-Americans and Latinos —in the sense that back in the ’60s, the family structure was much more solid,” Denver Mayor Michael Hancock said. “There were more men in the house. There were less single women trying to raise children on their own.

“The family structure has disintegrated in a sense. That challenge is real.”

While many single parents raise thriving, productive children, the growing trend of fatherless homes has enormous implications for future generations. Children raised in female-headed homes in Colorado are four times more likely to live in poverty than those from married-couple homes, according to the I-News analysis. Other studies show they are less likely to go to college or even graduate high school.

‘‘We’ve got a problem in the community, and every indicator that you can attribute to fatherless or broken homes, every negative thing — high dropout rates, incarceration, premature death related to violence — all those things, there’s a connection with kids being born to fractured families,” said Christelyn D. Karazin, founder of the “No Wedding, No Womb!” online initiative that seeks to address the out-of-wedlock birthrate among African-Americans.

Regina Huerter, co-founder of the Gang Rescue And Support Project in Denver, which primarily serves Hispanic youths, theorized that the widening divide between the races stems from a “mutually reinforcing” convergence of births to unwed mothers, growing minority male incarceration rates and the demise of minority neighborhoods.

All of these things weakened the fabric of family life and changed the norms that defined communities just five decades ago, Huerter said. At some point, she said, it became socially acceptable for unmarried women to have babies.

“When did that happen? What was the date? My mother would have killed me if I’d gotten pregnant,” said Huerter, who is 52.

Absence of fathers

Huerter, Hancock and others linked the absence of fathers in the home, in part, to the rising number of black and Latino men in prisons, often for drug crimes.

In 2010, about one in every 20 black men were incarcerated in Colorado state prisons compared to one out of every 50 Latino men and one of every 150 white men, according to an I-News analysis of government figures.

The state’s black and Latino incarceration rates are higher than the national averages, where disparities also exist, according to an analysis of Bureau of Justice reports. Nationally, one of every 33 black men and one of every 83 Latino men was behind bars in 2010. Colorado’s rate for white men was equivalent to the national figure, one in 150.

“The combination of the war on crack and mandatory sentencing saw a huge sweep of black males into prison and further degeneration of the black family,” said Theo Wilson, a district director for BarberShop Talk, a mentorship organization for men.

The Rev. Leon Kelly, who has worked with thousands of Denver’s at-risk inner city kids, thinks intergenerational abandonment lies at the heart of the single-parenthood phenomenon.

“When you have some of these heads of household that are women, sometimes they feel like, ‘This is the norm. This is what I was raised with,’” Kelly said. “They’re so used to people coming in and out of their life. With their kids, their babies, it’s something that nobody can take away. Their kids are going to be there.”

Kelly said 80 percent of the youths he counsels live in female-headed households.

“A lot of them never had men on a consistent basis in the home to show them what they should be doing as far as being the head of the household,” Kelly said. “A lot of them join gangs because at least they’re able to find a sense of identity, a sense of acceptance. Now he’s not just a fatherless child. “

Overlooking red flags

Angel Castro’s 3-year-old son, Aaron, already has lived in 10 different shelters, hotel rooms and apartments. By the time Alexis was born in August 2011, Castro had landed her Englewood apartment through the Colorado Coalition for the Homeless, which pays all but $54 of her monthly rent.

With no financial support from the fathers of her children, Castro scrapes money together any way she can. She makes burritos to sell on city buses. She raids Dumpsters for metal and aluminum, cleans houses and has evicted deadbeat renters, trained dogs and sold her plasma.

Castro’s mother endured struggles of her own. She was just 16 when she gave birth to Angel, the first of her six children by three men. Castro said her father has eight children by five different women.

Throughout her childhood, Castro lived in countless foster homes and group homes. By the time she was 12, she was living with her 22-year-old boyfriend at his house in Aurora. As a teenager, she was involved in an assault that landed her in prison.

As for the men who fathered her children, she said, “I overlooked a lot of red flags. I was searching for that bond with both of my children’s fathers and having that family I always wanted.”

Welfare failures

Conservatives and liberals cite the impact of welfare programs on families as a major factor in the growing divide between the races, though for different reasons. Some said cutbacks in government support disproportionately hurt minorities while others said the system encourages dependence on government and keeps minorities and the poor from improving their future.

Former U.S. Sen. Hank Brown said the welfare system rewards behavior that leads to poverty.

“Most states operate in a way so that the more children you have out of wedlock, the more money you get,” Brown said. “If you chart it, I know this is painful to hear, but if you look at the statistics on births to unmarried women, it correlates directly with the start” of welfare payments. “Then, of course, once you start the cycle, it’s hard to get off.”

But former Denver Mayor Wellington Webb said welfare reform that passed under President Bill Clinton catapulted “a lot of people who were receiving government assistance off into a kind of a Never Never Land, which also then increased the number of disadvantaged that previously had been receiving assistance.”

This Gordian knot can be untangled, according to Isabel V. Sawhill and Ron Haskins, senior fellows at the Brookings Institution, the Washington, D.C., think tank. Their 2009 book called “Creating an Opportunity Society” advocates increased educational opportunities for children from pre-school on, encouraging and supporting work among adults, and reducing the number of out-of-wedlock births while increasing the number of children raised by their married parents.

In an interview with I-News, Sawhill said the huge increase in single parenthood factors into the disparities between the races, particularly between blacks and whites.

“It’s one of the reasons why that gap has not narrowed, especially since the 1970s,” she said.

Sawhill and Haskins also have used census data and simple modeling to simulate what would happen to poverty rates under different assumptions about work, marriage, education and family size among the poor. They found that the poverty rate could be reduced by about 70 percent if the poor completed high school, married, had no more than two children and worked full time.

The researchers also ran a model in which they doubled the amount of welfare benefits received by poor families.

“The result is revealing,” they wrote. “Even a doubling of current benefit levels does less to reduce poverty than any of the simulations of behavior change. … Work, marriage, education and family size are all more powerful determinants of the incidence of poverty than the amount of cash assistance received from the government.”

Sawhill told I-News that inequities will only end through a combination of personal responsibility and good government policy, including assistance for those who work. “We think it isn’t one or the other,” she said. “It’s both.”

Finding faith

When Denver’s mayor talks about the struggles of single parents, he does so through the prism of his own childhood.

The youngest of 10 children, Hancock was raised by a single mother after the divorce of his parents when he was 6. His father had a drinking problem and popped in and out of his life. His mother kept her brood together, hopscotching from rundown hotel rooms to apartments that sometimes lacked heat and electricity.

One of Hancock’s sisters was murdered by her boyfriend; a brother died of AIDS. One sibling was an alcoholic, another addicted to drugs. Two brothers served time in prison. But somehow, Hancock graduated high school and college, became the youngest CEO of an Urban League chapter anywhere in the country and was elected mayor of the nation’s 26th-largest city.

How did he rise above?

“My answer is really pretty simple,” he said. “I found faith at a very early age and exercised it a great deal growing up. Two, I had the benefit of being the youngest of 10 where I watched a lot of the trials and tribulations of older siblings, learning the pitfalls to avoid.

“Thirdly, I had a great deal of adults who entered my life, who gave me a sense of encouragement that I could be successful if I focused, who also kept me directed.”

When prodded, he offered this advice to disadvantaged children:

“Your circumstances today don’t have to define where you go or who you become tomorrow. My story is not unlike many stories of other successful people whether in business or in politics. The difference between those who are able to ascend to their dream of whatever they want to be in life, to those who don’t, really is about the decisions we make and really the desire and decision to focus on getting there. The reality is they control their destiny.”

Endless paperwork

For now, Angel Castro’s days revolve around trying to figure out how to feed and clothe Aaron and Alexis. She threw a small party a few months ago for Alexis’s first birthday and was relieved when she got gifts of diapers and wipes rather than toys.

She used to count herself lucky to have a neighbor who watched her children for $20 each week so that she could work. But Castro had to give up her position after her sitter got a better-paying job.

Castro is frustrated by the endless rules and paperwork of a welfare system she thinks is “built to set you up for failure.” She said she has only four hours per day of government-supported child care, which means she can’t work full time.

She sometimes thinks the only solution is to put Aaron and Alexis in foster care and hope for a better fate for them than she experienced.

“I’ve had a whole chaotic life, feeling hurt and angry with my whole situation,” Castro said. “I don’t want my kids feeling like I felt growing up.”

Losing Ground: "Colorado's Minorities"

Losing Ground "Colorado's Minorities" from I-News on Vimeo.

For more information, visit www.inewsnetwork.org. Email Ann Carnahan Espinola at aespinola@inewsnetwork.org. I-News intern Leia Larsen contributed to this report, which was made possible, in part, by grants from The Colorado Health Foundation and the French-American Foundation.

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Requires free registration

Posting comments requires a free account and verification.