Chief, sergeant resign

Caterinicchio, Foster leave Oak Creek Police Department


— Embattled Oak Creek Police Chief Russ Caterinicchio and Sgt. Erik Foster tendered their resignations Thursday. The Oak Creek Town Board unanimously accepted the resignations during its regular meeting Thursday night.

Caterinicchio submitted a letter of resignation at 5 p.m. Thursday, one hour after Foster gave his resignation verbally to town Trustee and Police Commissioner Chuck Wisecup. The town's community service officer, Tony VanDeventer, also resigned.

The Town Board convened at 7 p.m. and immediately went into executive session to discuss an undisclosed "personnel issue." After meeting behind closed doors for about 30 minutes, board members emerged and Wisecup moved to accept each of the resignations. None of the departing officers was in attendance.

The resignations seemed to come as a surprise to the standing-room only audience pouring out into the hallway, many of whom were in attendance with the expectation that the board would discuss a proposal developed last week by local business owners. That proposal called for Caterinicchio and Foster's terminations or resignations.

"I think we are all shocked," said Bonfiglio Drug owner David Bonfiglio, who helped organize recent meetings among Oak Creek business owners at the behest of the Town Board.

"We all hoped for this outcome, but we weren't expecting it go that way," Bonfiglio said.

Trustee and Police Commissioner Dave Ege said Caterinicchio and Foster resigned of their own volition.

"It was a surprise to me," Ege said.

Ege also noted that their resignations certainly were a better outcome than termination.

Caterinicchio and Foster had been under fire for what some town residents and business owners say were questionable policing methods and an approach to their jobs that didn't mesh with the community's policing mindset.

At the time of his resignation, Caterinicchio turned over chain of custody materials and the Oak Creek Police Department's evidence vault to Eileen Rossi, its sole remaining officer, and returned all town property, Wisecup said. Foster is expected to do the same today.

Board members did not address replacing the resigning officers, or any procedures or timeframe for doing so. The Town Board has not engaged in any such discussion, Wisecup said.

Rossi and police commissioners Ege and Wisecup are expected to take part in preliminary discussions today to determine how the department will run in the immediate future.

Rossi works part time for the department, between 20 and 32 hours a week, and noted that as a seasonal Routt County resident she typically leaves the state by the end of October.

"I'm going to be meeting with the various leaders to see what they expect of me - and if I'm willing to do it," Rossi said.

Routt County Sheriff Gary Wall and Undersheriff David Bustos attended Thursday's meeting and said they will work with Oak Creek's police commissioners and Rossi to ensure a smooth transition and provide law enforcement coverage of Oak Creek.

"The board cannot guarantee response times or anything like that at this point," Trustee Dave Fisher said.


In light of VanDeventer's resignation, the Town Board tabled its consideration of an abatement bid from Black Hawk-based Mondial Environmental. During the summer, the town directed its community service officer to give notice to property owners in violation of Oak Creek's nuisance ordinance.

Mondial Environmental submitted a bid of $1,250 for the 11 properties not brought into compliance, "to include hauling away any trash or scrap materials, mowing and general restoration of each property to its unabated state," according to the bid.

Although Fisher noted that the bid seemed "an exceptionally good value," the board designated Ege to get more information before the next board meeting. VanDeventer had carried out all previous conversations with Mondial Environmental about the scope of the work.

The board also unanimously renewed the liquor licenses of Black Mountain Tavern and Dinty Moore's Family Restaurant.


Scott Wedel 8 years, 6 months ago

The Town could never guarantee response times with Chief Russ and Erik. Sheriff's dept was often the first to respond.

And for the public record, Town Trustees Gerry Greenwood, Chuck Wisecup and Dave Fisher should disclose what they were talking about Wed and Thurs. It was apparent to many that they were extensively talking to each other two at a time and sometimes with Chief Russ.

The letter of the law says a meeting of 3 or more board members talking policy has to be an open meeting. It is not perfectly legal to have rotating meetings among three board members. It could easily been seen as a transparent attempt by three board members to discuss public policy and their proposals in secret.

At the very least, they should tell the Town Attorney what they were talking about and see if he thinks they need to disclose their conversations.


mtroach 8 years, 6 months ago

Maybe SSPD should hire these two to enforce our traffic laws.


Ed Miklus 8 years, 6 months ago

The citizens of Oak Creek and the Town Board should be commended. They have taken back control of their town and community. Our Founding Fathers would be proud.....government of the people, BY the people and FOR the people. Resignations, the only possible solution given the egregious nature of the situation.


Duke_bets 8 years, 6 months ago

The Town Board should absolutely NOT be commended. The Town Board was a big part of the problem by letting this linger and not following the direction of the elected leader. Does everyone remember when Mayor J was bashed for attempting to remove the OCPD some time ago? In fact, that was before the Cargo incident and many others. Bleuer, Fisher, and Wisecup owe Mayor J the mother of all opologies and should help fund the pending lawsuits with their own personal cash. If they would have taken the mayor's advice, the situation would not have blown up for the next several months.

This is the time that Russ should be commended. He stepped to the plate and realized that his unwillingness to change and the Town's unacceptance of change was not a good match.


eastboy 8 years, 6 months ago

All of the above were obviously correct. Now it will be interesting to see what the Town Board will do about it, if anything. Cause up to now, the tails been leading the donkey!


max huppert 8 years, 6 months ago

i am glad I dont have to worry about walking my dogs on a leash, and being able to take them into the Elks Tavern with me, dont need any police with 2 Rotties..


Scrapiron 8 years, 6 months ago

I am rather inclined to agree with what "Duke" has written. Of course, when we look at WHO owes J an apology....well, does one happen to be so naive as to think that ANY of these 3 members would have the charachter or Moxie to do so? I think not! Messrs. Bleuer, Wisecup & Fisher give the impression that they like power, like it a LOT, and therefore shouldn't even be allowed to sweep the floors of Town Hall let alone serve on the Board! Obviously, they were lousy history students, as anyone with an IQ of a rutebaga understands BASIC CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS of citizens, and from what I have read so far, Chief Russ and his minions were off the charts with their behaviour! They allowed the situation to snowball until it reached critical mass, thus producing the inevitable. I'm not so sure 'Chief Russ' deserves any commendation; perhaps he had an 'epiphany' and realized that resignation was much more pleasant than the humiliation of getting 'pulverized' in a trial that was worthy of national attention, he, being the obvious LOSER!


Requires free registration

Posting comments requires a free account and verification.