'Personhood' amendment defeated in a landslide


— Colorado won't become the first state to amend its constitution to give fertilized eggs the same rights as human beings, as voters soundly rejected Amendment 48.

The so-called Personhood Amendment was failing by a 3-to-1 ratio, and co-author Kristi Burton laid a lot of the blame for its demise at the feet of high-profile officials with strong anti-abortion credentials that refused to endorse it.

Burton pointed out that Republican U.S. Senate candidate Bob Schaffer and Colorado Republican Party Chairman Dick Wadhams hurt the amendment's chances when they "campaigned against this issue" publicly.

"That proved to be insurmountable," she said.

But Wadhams and Schaffer didn't actually campaign against it - they simply refused to endorse it, with Wadhams calling the measure the wrong avenue for the abortion fight.

The measure would have granted constitutional rights to a fertilized egg - including due process and inalienable rights.

The amendment fractured much of the anti-abortion establishment - with Burton unable to round up such notable abortion opponents as Denver Archbishop Charles Chaput and National Right to Life.

But the political arm of Focus on the Family did support it, and Burton was aided by several other anti-abortion groups and some Colorado candidates willing to endorse the measure - including Scott Helman, who was running for a state Senate seat in Weld County

Fofi Mendez, the No on 48 campaign manager, said the splintering of the anti-abortion groups proved the point they made their campaign slogan - that the amendment "went too far."

"We knew when Coloradans understood the far-reaching consequences of the amendment, they'd vote no," Mendez said.

"The credit goes to our 5,300 individuals who volunteered, donated and fought against this."


John Archibold 8 years, 5 months ago

The first paragrapoh of your news story re Amendment 48 states that fertilized eggs won't be given the same rights as human beings--this implies that there are two distinct categories--fertilized eggs and human beings. But there are not two categories since fertilized eggs are a subcategory of human beings just as are zygotes, embryos, fetuses, infants, toddlers, children, adolescents, and adults are. The Colorado Supreme Court, prior to the legalization of abortion in 1967, said that a child includes the unborn from the moment of conception. Amendment 48 merely wanted to return to that protection. Amendment 48 said nothing about unborn children having to have passport, get drivers' licenses, being able to vote, and the myriad of other "issues" of like kind that opponents threw up to muddy the waters.


Duke_bets 8 years, 5 months ago

John - 48 was absolutely ridiculous. The votes nationwide support the absurdity of the Amendement. To me, it was a feeble advertising attempt by the Pro-Lifers.


WZ 8 years, 5 months ago

I'd give it my support if I'd get a child tax deduction for every egg I helped to fertilize in a given tax year! ;P


tsegler 8 years, 5 months ago

Please remember, voters - that had Amendment O passed, we would not have to see all of these ballot issues on election day.


playa46 8 years, 5 months ago

This is crazy, why are some of us still made at the results? Of course, I am pro-choice so I would not like this to be passed.

What's wrong with abortion? You're going to die anyway, it simply depends on how you go out, there's nothing you can do about it.


Requires free registration

Posting comments requires a free account and verification.