Archive for Friday, December 28, 2007
Margaret Hair: See you in 2008
Advertisement
Margaret Hair
Margaret Hair's column appears Fridays in the 4 Points arts and entertainment section in the Steamboat Today. Contact her at 871-4204 or e-mail mhair@steamboatpilot.com.
Steamboat Springs For those who follow arts and entertainment reporting in just about any publication in the country, you'll notice something around the middle of December every year:
Arts writers love to make lists.
That can mean ranking favorite releases from the previous 12 months (see page 4), reflecting on the events that have shaped how we look at our community (see page 9) or plotting out one last night to say goodbye to 2007 (see page 8).
Do we do this because it's easy, because it's easier to write in bullet points than in coherent paragraphs that flow from one to the next?
No.
You'll find lists of the top 10 records of 2007 in almost every music media outlet you see for the same reason that people make New Year's resolutions - putting them together gives you a chance to look back on what's important to you, weigh the impact and move on.
Say, for example, you've been trying to get up at 6 a.m. and go run on a treadmill before work for the last, I don't know, four months. And it's never actually happened, so you resolve to start getting up and running on the treadmill, just as soon as 6 a.m. on Jan. 2 rolls around.
But that's still a few days away, which gives ample time to reflect on the year that's gone by and remember why exactly that gym-in-the-morning thing never happened.
Now say you listen to new music as it comes out and are trying decide what made the biggest impact on you. For the list in this edition of 4 Points, eight people from around town and the Pilot & Today staff listed and ranked their favorites, and the results were compiled into the list you'll find on the other side of this page.
Putting together my list took at least as much reflection on the past year as the thought process that goes into not ever making it to work out.
The first time I heard some of those records, I was a floundering college senior/library publicist/newspaper editor/record store clerk/sandwich shop manager living in Carrboro, N.C. If you had told me I would be living in Steamboat Springs by the time I heard the list's more recent releases, I would have asked you if steamboats could actually fit down any river in Colorado.
We approach media based on our lifestyles, and I probably would have heard something different listening to my favorite record of the year, Josh Ritter's "The Historical Conquests of Josh Ritter," in May than I would have in November.
The same goes for resolutions - what we want to change about ourselves (except possibly for the standbys of being healthier, smarter, nicer, better people), changes with our surroundings and our experiences.
Sure, writers make top 10 lists and do year in review roundups to recap the news, but they also do them to recap their own lives.
Lists also offer writers a handy excuse to skip resolutions. We already did our reflecting.

Comments
dimwitiguess (anonymous) says...
Maggie,
Next year please don't write about new year's resolutions. That is just not interesting anymore. I haven't paid attention to your illustrious career as a reporter or a writer, but this topic is well worn, so worn that even the sock inside the worn shoe has a hole in it. This is no incrimination of you this is an incrimination of the Pilot and it's penchant for the "trite and true." I can see Tom Ross or Scott Stanford writing this because, well you'd just expect that kind of article from them. But please you have a whole career in front of you.
Help yourseld and avoid the resolution article no matter how tempting it may be in any future year. Yeh, sure, I know the arguments for it, but pick something like Christmas returns after the new year, or new year's cookie treats, or new year's activities like diving into the freezing waters of some murky lake.
Better yet, pretend there is no new years and write about the football playoffs or the Chicago Bulls failure to thrive, or the continuing problems of the Broncos's playoff dreams. Pretend that new years is a few weeks away on the Gregarian calendar. Anything, but please don't write about new year's resolutions.
Hell, my resolution is to count how many articles the Pilot can write that actually count for anything in our lives. Fortunately, it's not the new year yet, so maybe the Pilot will make a resolution to improve their reporting and writing skills and improving their skill about "what to leave in and what to leave out" as Bob Seger would say.
Thanks for trying. I rate your article a C-, and would write "trite" or "vague" or "over done" or as one of my teachers wrote on my paper once "BORING. Your paper put me to sleep!"
I'm not complaining, and if I am, MAYBE I'll make a new year's resolution to stop complaining. Either way, that's MY point of view, but then everyone thinks I'm a dimwitiguess.
December 28, 2007 at 10:41 p.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
blahblahblah (anonymous) says...
Maggie,
Keep up the good work.
Everyone is a critic but not everybody is a writer. Some of us are cheesed off about that... I guess.
January 2, 2008 at 9:50 a.m. ( permalink | suggest removal )
Post a comment (Requires free registration)
Posting comments requires a free account and verification.