Our View: Balance returns in election


The results of the 2006 election demonstrate that, at a minimum, Routt County is once again home to two political parties.

There was a time not so long ago when the Democrats could barely get candidates to run for local office, much less win seats. As recently as 2004, the only Democrat to hold county office was Doug Monger.

But the local Democratic Party demonstrated considerable muscle this time around, winning all three locally contested races. Those wins, in part, were a result of state and national trends; however, they also were the result of the local party being more organized than it has been in the past.

That's a good development for Routt County. It's our thought that when both parties are active and engaged, there are more and better candidates for office and the elections produce more substantive debate.

Given the results, local Democrats might think the 2006 election produced a mandate of sorts for more liberal policies or issues. And it is true that Routt County election results were 7 to 15 percentage points to the left of state and national results. The only Republican to carry Routt County was state Rep. Al White.

But we would caution Democratic officeholders and Democrats in general that registered Republicans still outnumber registered Democrats in the county. And although four of our county officeholders are now Democrats, the other four are Republicans. And both of Routt County's state legislators - White and state Sen. Jack Taylor - also are Republicans.

There are other items worthy of noting from the election:

n Democrat Gary Wall won the race for sheriff by taking the city of Steamboat Springs by an overwhelming margin over Republican Garrett Wiggins. Wall actually lost the overall vote and seven of the 10 precincts in the county. Those are numbers Wall should keep in mind, considering that the sheriff has almost no law enforcement role in the city limits.

n With the election of Diane Mitsch Bush, the Democrats suddenly have control of the Routt County Board of Commissioners. But we would be surprised if this produces significant change. The bond between Democratic Commissioner Doug Monger and Republican Commissioner Nancy Stahoviak comes from working together for years and goes beyond party affiliation.

n The dissatisfaction with the war in Iraq and national scandals involving Republicans had an impact everywhere, including Routt County. Local Democratic candidates clearly benefited from these national trends, which likely inflated their election results.

n There are about 5,000 registered Republicans in Routt County and 4,200 registered Democrats. Based on the election results, a lot of Republicans stayed home or unaffiliated voters broke for the Democrats in a big, big way. Either way, the local Republican Party has work to do.

The reality is that party affiliation has little to do with being sheriff or being assessor or being a county commissioner. The job descriptions are pretty well- defined, and those hoping to see a noticeable change based on whether a Republican or Democrat was elected are likely to be disappointed.

Rather, the emergence of the Democratic Party in Routt County simply means we now have more candidates, better candidates and better funding. That means voters have more choices and better choices. That's a good thing for the county's voters.


Murray Tucker 10 years, 5 months ago

Yes, Republicans outnumber Democrats in Routt County. But the important group is the unaffiliated. The Democrat Party provided a slate of local candidates that appealed to those unaffiliated and swept the local elections. The fact that Al White won reelection is indicative that the R label was not a total hindrance, or that the preponderance of Republicans in HD 57 overwhelmed a good showing by Andy Gold.

I would hope that local elections (City and County) would move to non partisan in the future. There are those of us who could not vote for a person with an R. Others who could not X for a Dem. The party label for local elections is shorthand for too many of us and we overlook candidates who will serve us best.


Tigger 10 years, 5 months ago

Hmmm Gary Wall vs. Garrett Wiggins, I just think too many people KNEW Wiggins, lol. Dianne Bush ran a killer campaign. She came to my house to speak with me and earned my vote. I did not see Paul Strong hitting the pavement. Also, how much time could P.S dedicate to the job while on city council, another bad mark against him, and running a business? Dianne was the clear choice. The 2004 elections was about gay marriage, abortion and the war. The red party ran a campaign based on fear and "morals". Are we more secure? The answer is no. Our borders are broken and the war in Iraq, as well as the middle east stabilization, continues to deteriorate. So after the red party runs a camp based on morals, Tom Delay and Jack Abromof get busted. They were even being lobbied by sweat shops. Now we have Foley, a gay alcholic, who is on a party that is against gay marriage, like it is an issue with the way the world is going. Bush keeps stating things are going well in Iraq, I swear this war will break us. $$$$$$ Now we are engaging in more free trade agreements despite the fact that the current adminstration and seat holders refuse to take action against China breaking the rules of the agreement. What did you seriously expect? I don't think salvation will come from the blue or red parties, but firing thier asses out of washington, well as many as we could sent a messege that the PEOPLE are now paying close attention, and we don't like the way things are run!! I reccomend ditching lobbiest for a good first step.


another_local 10 years, 5 months ago

When I first arrived here I registered to vote. I did not select a party affiliation but somehow I turned out to be registered as a republican.

Since a very small number of registered voters who do have a party affiliation choose to participate in the primary elections, they have very little inclination to go change the affiliation if even if they have changed their voting patterns.

As mentioned above, independent is a huge chunk of the public out there. How many registered voters are there altogether? Is un-affiliated bigger than either party?

I don't think that the republicans stayed home.


Requires free registration

Posting comments requires a free account and verification.